Casting vs Forging: Steel Processes

Quick Reference

Casting: steel melted and poured into molds for complex shapes (gears, valve bodies, machinery). Forging: heated solid steel shaped under pressure for superior strength (shafts, fasteners, forged fittings). Forged products have finer grain structure, better tensile strength, and higher fatigue resistance. Castings offer design flexibility for intricate geometries.

Cast vs forged steel classification

Steel Forging vs. Casting

Basic Definitions

Steel casting and forging are two fundamental manufacturing processes for forming steel into finished products. Each method produces parts with distinct mechanical properties and geometries, so the choice between them depends on the application’s strength requirements, shape complexity, and production volume.

Steel Casting

Steel casting involves melting steel to a liquid state and pouring it into a mold, where it solidifies into a specific shape. The process excels at producing complex geometries and components that would be difficult or impossible to manufacture by other methods. Cast steel products range from simple gears and valves to intricate heavy machinery and automotive assemblies.

Common casting applications include automotive, mining, aerospace, and construction, basically any industry where complex shapes or specialized alloy compositions are needed.

Steel Forging

Forging involves heating solid steel blocks (ingots or billets) and deforming them under high pressure or impact to achieve the desired shape. The process can be performed at different temperatures, yielding classifications of cold forging, warm forging, and hot forging.

Steel forging dominates in industries that demand high-strength components: automotive and aerospace for gears, shafts, and levers, as well as critical fasteners and valves.

Both manufacturing processes require high temperatures applied to steel raw materials (to liquefy or make it malleable) and CNC machining at the end of the process to produce the final product.

Final products may also undergo surface finish treatments such as painting, powder coating, polishing, zinc plating, or wear protection/hardening (tungsten carbide overlay).

Cast and forged parts may be assembled, welded, brazed, and hard-faced before being shipped as final products.

The products from casting and forging differ in surface porosity (generally better for forged vs. cast products), grain structure (finer for forged products), tensile strength (generally superior for forged products), and fatigue resistance.

These manufacturing processes are therefore suited for different circumstances and applications.

Choosing Between Cast & Forged Products

Decision Factor	Casting	Forging
Design complexity	Complex shapes, internal cavities	Simpler shapes (complex = expensive)
Size	Virtually unlimited	Limited by press capacity
Material properties	Wide alloy selection	Superior strength/toughness
Production volume	Better for small-medium batches	Better for large runs
Initial cost	High mold cost, lower unit cost at volume	High tooling cost, efficient at scale
Integrity	May have porosity	No voids, consistent properties

When to choose CASTING:

• Parts too complex or expensive to forge (e.g., large valve bodies)
• Parts with internal cavities
• Very large parts with no practical size limit
• Special alloys difficult to forge (high Ni/Mo content)
• Small lot production where forging dies aren’t justified

When to choose FORGING:

• Maximum strength, toughness, and fatigue resistance required
• Parts subject to high impact and mechanical stress
• Zero tolerance for porosity, voids, or gas pockets
• High wear resistance needed
• High-end applications where quality and integrity outweigh cost/time
• Critical pressure-containing components

The evolution of casting technologies has reduced the gap between the physical properties of cast vs. forged products making modern cast products very competitive in terms of quality, strength, and wear resistance: however, in many fields, steel forging remains, still, the preferred manufacturing option (example: small sized valves, i.e. forged valves, or high-pressure valves).

Pro Tip

When the spec says “forged” but you’re quoted cast products at a lower price, don’t assume they’re equivalent. Forged components are specified for a reason - usually fatigue resistance or pressure integrity in critical service. Substituting cast for forged without engineering review can lead to field failures, especially in cyclic pressure or high-vibration applications.

Read about forging steel on Wikipedia.

Fields of Application

Steel casting and forging produce parts and products for many sectors:

• petrochemical plants (for example forged valves, forged fittings, flanges, etc)
• power generation and waste processing
• mining and mineral processing
• agriculture and livestock handling
• water treatment
• aeronautics
• automobile industry (pulleys and gear wheels)
• materials handling
• brickworks
• asphalt plants
• stormwater parts
• rendering plants
• railways

Steel Casting

Definition

Steel casting is a manufacturing process in which steel is melted to a liquid state, poured into a mold, and allowed to solidify into the desired shape. The method produces parts with complex geometries and detailed features that other processes cannot easily replicate.

cast valve body

Molds can be sand, metal, or ceramic, depending on the required precision, surface finish, and reuse cycle. Steel castings serve the automotive, aerospace, construction, and energy sectors because of their flexibility in shape and size, combined with the ability to tailor material properties through alloy selection and post-casting heat treatment.

The process is particularly valuable for components that demand high strength, durability, and resistance to wear and corrosion.

Steel casting process flow

Steel Casting Process

The steel casting process transforms raw steel into precisely shaped components through a sequence of well-defined steps.

Casting Process: Pattern Making → Mold Making → Melting & Pouring → Solidification → Mold Removal → Cleaning & Finishing → Inspection & QC

Step	Operation	Details
1	Pattern Making	A pattern representing the final shape is created from wood, plastic, or metal, slightly oversized to account for shrinkage.
2	Mold Making	Molding material (sand with binders) is packed around the pattern. When the pattern is removed, the cavity matches the part shape. Complex parts use two-half molds (cope and drag) with cores for internal cavities.
3	Melting and Pouring	Steel is melted at >1600 °C (2900 °F) with controlled alloy composition, then poured into the mold carefully to fill all sections and avoid defects.
4	Solidification and Cooling	Steel cools and solidifies in the mold. Cooling rates affect microstructure; directional solidification minimizes stresses and defects.
5	Mold Removal	Sand molds are broken away; metal molds are opened and reused.
6	Cleaning and Finishing	Residual mold material is removed, gates/runners cut off. Parts undergo grinding, machining, and heat treatment to reach final properties.
7	Inspection and QC	Dimensional accuracy and material properties are verified. NDT methods (X-ray, ultrasonic) detect internal defects.

Advantages/disadvantages Of Cast Steel

Advantages

Cast steel combines design freedom with strong mechanical performance. The casting process itself and the intrinsic properties of steel create a set of practical benefits.

1. Design Flexibility

Cast steel allows production of complex shapes and intricate designs that are difficult or impossible to achieve through forging or machining. Engineers can incorporate internal cavities, contours, and complex external geometries in a single piece, eliminating assembly or welding of multiple parts.

2. Material Properties

Steel casting works with a broad range of alloys, so the composition can be adjusted to optimize strength, ductility, wear resistance, impact resistance, or corrosion resistance. Post-casting heat treatments provide additional control over mechanical properties.

3. Large Component Production

The casting process handles large components that would be prohibitively expensive to forge or machine from solid billet. This matters in mining, construction, maritime, and energy, where oversized, durable parts are standard.

4. Cost-Effectiveness

For small to medium production volumes, casting is often more economical than alternative methods, especially for complex shapes that would require extensive machining or multi-part assembly. Near-net-shape production reduces material waste and secondary processing.

5. Surface Finish and Detail

Cast steel achieves a good surface finish and fine detail directly from the mold, which limits the need for post-processing. This benefits parts with tight dimensional requirements or aesthetic constraints.

6. Reliability

Steel castings undergo rigorous quality control and testing. Non-destructive testing (NDT) techniques (X-ray, ultrasonic, and magnetic particle inspection) detect internal or surface defects before the part enters service.

7. Speed to Market

The casting process moves quickly from design to production, especially for prototypes or limited runs. This short turnaround cuts lead time for new products and components.

The combination of design freedom, tunable material properties, and economical production makes cast steel a practical choice across industrial applications, from heavy machinery and automotive components to architectural elements.

Disadvantages

Cast steel has well-known limitations that engineers must weigh against its advantages.

1. Cost

Specialized molds can be expensive to manufacture, particularly for intricate designs or low production volumes. Alloyed steels used in casting for enhanced properties add further material cost.

2. Surface Finish and Tolerances

Cast steel typically has a rougher surface finish than forged or machined parts, requiring additional finishing. Tight dimensional tolerances are harder to hold, especially on complex shapes or large components, and often demand further machining.

3. Porosity and Defects

The casting process can introduce porosity (tiny holes or voids) that reduces mechanical strength and pressure integrity. Castings are also susceptible to shrinkage cavities, cold shuts, and inclusions. All of these require rigorous inspection and quality control to detect.

Common Mistake

Accepting cast valve bodies based on visual inspection alone. Surface appearance tells you nothing about internal porosity or shrinkage voids - always require radiographic (RT) or ultrasonic (UT) examination for pressure-containing castings. The cost of NDT is negligible compared to the cost of a field failure.

4. Material Limitations

Some alloy compositions are not suitable for casting because of their melting behavior or reactivity with mold materials. There are also practical limits to the size and weight of cast components, driven by foundry equipment capacity and the difficulty of maintaining uniform heat dissipation across large sections.

5. Environmental Considerations

Melting and casting steel consumes significant energy. The process also generates waste (spent molds, excess metal from gates and risers, and defective castings) that must be managed and recycled where possible.

Types of Steel Casting Processes

Process	Best For	Size/Volume
Sand Casting	Large parts, versatile shapes	Large, small-medium runs
Investment (Lost Wax)	Complex details, tight tolerances	Up to 100kg, 1.5m max
Centrifugal	Cylindrical parts (pipes, rings)	Any cylindrical shape
Continuous	Basic shapes for further processing	Billets, blooms, slabs
Shell Molding	Better finish than sand	Medium-high volume
Vacuum	High-integrity, defect-free	Aerospace, power generation
Die Casting	High-volume small parts	Primarily non-ferrous metals

Sand Casting

Sand casting is the oldest casting method. Liquid metal is poured into binders that resist the molten steel (such as clay bonded/green sand, hard bonded/resin, thermosetting resin sand, and shell).

This is the most common and versatile method, using sand molds to create steel parts. The sand can be shaped into complex forms, making it suitable for automotive frames, heavy machinery components, and decorative pieces.

Investment Casting (Lost Wax Casting)

Investment casting uses precision molds formed by injecting liquid metal into a metal die and applying a ceramic coating. The mold material can be hard wax, lost wax, lost foam, or similar. This method is preferred for parts with fine detail and small parts where traditional sand casting would be too costly.

A wax model is coated with refractory material to create a mold. After the wax is melted out, molten steel is poured into the cavity. The result is excellent surface finish and dimensional accuracy, well suited for small, complex components with tight tolerances: turbine blades, medical equipment, and firearm components.

Centrifugal Casting

Molten steel is poured into a rotating mold, producing parts with cylindrical shapes. The centrifugal force pushes the molten steel against the mold walls, creating a dense and uniform casting. This method is used for components requiring high material integrity: pipes, cylinders, and rings.

Continuous Casting

A highly efficient process where molten steel solidifies in a continuous strand through a mold, then is cut into desired lengths. This method significantly reduces the need for further processing. It primarily produces basic shapes (billets, blooms, and slabs) which are then rolled or otherwise processed into finished steel products.

Shell Molding

Similar to sand casting, but uses a resin-coated sand that bonds to form a shell around the pattern. Shell molding offers a better surface finish and tighter dimensions than traditional sand casting. It suits medium to high-volume production of small to medium-sized parts such as valve components and gear housings.

Vacuum Casting

Molten steel is poured into a mold under vacuum. The vacuum reduces defects and improves casting quality by minimizing turbulence and gas entrapment. This process is used for high-integrity components that must be free of pores and voids, particularly in aerospace and power generation.

Die Casting

Die casting is predominantly used with non-ferrous metals because of steel’s high melting point, but specialized high-pressure die-casting processes can handle steel alloys. The method suits high-volume production of small, precise components that need a good surface finish.

Steel Forging

Definition

Steel forging is a manufacturing process that shapes metal using localized compressive forces. Steel is heated to a high temperature to become pliable, then hammered, pressed, or rolled into the desired shape.

The process can be performed at different temperatures (hot forging, warm forging, and cold forging), each producing distinct results in terms of ductility and finished-part properties.

Steel forging originated in ancient China for producing metal products.

The methods and equipment have evolved from traditional anvils, hammers, and manual labor to modern automated machinery like hydraulic presses, but the fundamental process remains the same: heating solid steel blocks and shaping them into finished products through mechanical force.

Steel forging process flow

Forging Process

The steel forging process transforms steel into strong, durable components through force and heat:

Forging Process: Material Selection → Heating → Forging → Shaping → Trimming → Heat Treatment → Finishing → Inspection & Testing

Step	Operation	Details
1	Material Selection	Steel grade chosen based on required strength, ductility, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance. Common grades: carbon steel, alloy steel, stainless steel, tool steel.
2	Heating	Steel is heated to 950-1250 °C (1742-2282 °F) to become pliable. Temperature varies by steel type and forging method (hot, warm, or cold).
3	Forging	Steel is shaped by hammer forging (repeated hammer strikes for precise shapes), press forging (hydraulic/mechanical press applies gradual pressure, with better control, suited for large production), or rolled forging (steel passes through rolls to decrease thickness and increase length, typically for cylindrical shapes).
4	Shaping	Internal grain structure deforms to conform to the part shape, increasing strength and toughness.
5	Trimming	Excess material (flash) is removed while hot or after cooling.
6	Heat Treatment	Annealing, normalizing, quenching, or tempering adjusts hardness and ductility while relieving internal stresses.
7	Finishing	Machining, grinding, and polishing achieve final surface finish and dimensions.
8	Inspection & Testing	Dimensional checks, visual inspection, and NDT methods (ultrasonic, magnetic particle) verify quality.

The resulting products possess high strength, impact toughness, and wear resistance. These properties come from the metallurgical changes (specifically recrystallization and grain refinement) that occur during the thermal and mechanical treatments of the forging process.

Field Note

For critical applications like high-pressure valve bodies or turbine components, request grain flow documentation from the forge. The forging die design should orient grain flow parallel to the primary stress direction - a poorly designed forging with grain flow perpendicular to stress behaves little better than a casting in fatigue service.

The video below shows how steel forging works:

Advantages/disadvantages Of Forged Steel

Forged steel is a preferred material for many industrial applications because of its strength and reliability. Like any manufacturing process, however, forging has trade-offs worth understanding.

Advantages of Forged Steel

1. Superior Strength and Toughness

Forging refines the grain structure and aligns it with the part’s shape. This grain refinement makes forged parts stronger and more resistant to impact and fatigue than cast or machined equivalents.

2. Improved Reliability

The forging process produces parts with consistent material properties and no internal voids, cracks, or other defects. This uniformity delivers high reliability, especially in critical applications.

3. Reduced Material Waste

Modern forging techniques are highly efficient, generating less scrap than casting or machining. This efficiency translates to cost savings in high-volume production.

4. Versatility in Materials

Steel forging works with a broad range of alloys, allowing production of parts with properties tailored to the application, whether high-temperature resistance, corrosion resistance, or wear resistance.

5. Cost-Effective for Large Production Runs

Initial setup and tooling costs are significant, but forging becomes more economical than other processes at high volumes due to material efficiency and reduced secondary processing.

Disadvantages of Forged Steel

1. Higher Initial Costs

Setup and die costs are substantial, especially for complex shapes. This makes forging less economical for small production runs.

2. Limitations on Shape Complexity

Forging handles a range of shapes, but extremely complex or intricate designs may require additional machining or alternative manufacturing steps.

3. Size Limitations

Forging size is constrained by press and hammer capacity. Very large components may be impractical to forge and require alternative methods.

4. Need for Secondary Processing

Depending on the application, forged parts may require machining, heat treatment, or surface finishing to achieve final dimensions, properties, or surface quality.

5. Energy Intensive

Hot forging in particular requires large amounts of energy to heat the metal, which adds to the environmental footprint of the process.

Types of Steel Forging Processes

Steel forging processes vary by technique and application. They are categorized by temperature (cold, warm, or hot) and by the method of applying force (hammer or press).

By Temperature:

Type	Temperature	Advantages	Best For
Hot Forging	950-1250°C (1742-2282°F)	Easy shaping, less force needed, no strain hardening	Complex shapes, high strength parts (automotive, construction)
Warm Forging	650-950°C (1202-1742°F)	Balance of formability and precision	Medium-complexity parts, cost-effective
Cold Forging	Room temperature	Excellent surface finish, work hardening strengthens part	Small precision parts (fasteners, bolts, screws)

Hot forging allows steel to be shaped easily because the high temperature increases plasticity and reduces resistance to deformation. Complex shapes require less force and energy, and strain hardening does not occur during the process.

Cold forging is performed at or near room temperature. It yields a cleaner finish and stronger products through strain hardening. Parts have excellent surface finish and dimensional accuracy; the steel’s strength increases through work hardening.

Warm forging sits between hot and cold forging, combining reduced force requirements with better dimensional accuracy than hot forging.

4. Open-Die Forging

In open-die forging, steel is worked between two flat or simply contoured dies that do not enclose the workpiece, allowing material to flow outward as it is forged. The process is highly versatile, capable of producing very large parts, and allows repositioning of the workpiece during forging. It is used for large, simple shapes: shafts, bars, beams, and plates.

Open die forging involves shaping metal by pressing or hammering it between two dies that don’t entirely enclose the material. The piece of metal is worked upon through successive movements of the dies, which apply force to mold the metal into the desired shape. This technique is demonstrated in the action showcased in the video below:

5. Closed-Die Forging (Impression-Die Forging)

In closed-die forging, steel is compressed between two or more dies containing a precut profile of the desired part, producing a more precise and complex shape. The process yields close tolerances with minimal waste and suits high-volume production. Automotive, aerospace, and industrial components that require detailed features and high strength are typical applications.

Closed-die forging is a process where the dies close in on the workpiece, either completely enclosing it or partially. The process begins by placing a piece of heated raw material, roughly shaped or sized to match the final product, into the lower die. This process is demonstrated in the following video:

6. Seamless Rolled Ring Forging

Seamless rolled ring forging starts by piercing a hole in a thick, round piece of metal to create a donut shape, which is then rolled and stretched into a seamless ring. The process efficiently produces rings with excellent structural integrity and uniform properties. Typical products include bearings, flanges, gear rings, and wind turbine components.

Difference between Open-Die & Closed-Die Forging

Feature	Open-Die Forging	Closed-Die Forging
Die configuration	Flat dies, workpiece not enclosed	Dies contain precut profile, enclose workpiece
Size capability	Very large parts possible	Limited by die size and press capacity
Precision	Lower - requires machining	High - close tolerances, minimal machining
Complexity	Simple shapes only	Complex geometries with details
Production volume	Low volume, one-offs	High volume, mass production
Material waste	Higher (less precise shape)	Lower (near-net shape)
Setup cost	Lower	Higher (complex dies)
Unit cost	Higher at volume	Lower at volume
Applications	Shafts, beams, large industrial parts	Gears, levers, fasteners, automotive/aerospace

Related Steel Products

Structural Steel Sections

• Steel Plates - Hot-rolled plates for construction and manufacturing
• IPE/IPN Steel Beams - European I-beam profiles for structural applications
• HSS Hollow Sections - Square and rectangular tubular sections
• RSA Steel Angles - Equal and unequal angle sections
• UPN/UPE Channels - U-shaped channel sections

Material Properties

• Density of Metals - Reference table for metal densities
• CE Marking for Steel Products - European conformity requirements for construction products

Related quick answers: Cast vs Forged Steel | What Is Hardness Comparison?