What Is Weld Decay? Sensitization
Weld decay is a form of intergranular corrosion that occurs in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of austenitic stainless steel welds. During welding, the HAZ is heated to 450-850 deg C (the sensitization temperature range), causing chromium to combine with carbon and precipitate as chromium carbides (Cr23C6) along the grain boundaries. This depletes the adjacent grain boundary region of chromium below the 10.5% minimum needed for corrosion resistance, leaving a narrow zone vulnerable to preferential attack in corrosive environments.
How Weld Decay Develops
The process occurs in three steps:
- Heating: Welding heats the HAZ into the sensitization range (450-850 deg C)
- Carbide precipitation: Carbon diffuses to grain boundaries and combines with chromium to form Cr23C6
- Chromium depletion: The zone immediately surrounding each grain boundary loses chromium below the passivation threshold
In service, a corrosive medium (acids, chlorides, or even aerated water) attacks the chromium-depleted grain boundaries preferentially, causing the grains to detach. The corrosion pattern follows a band parallel to the weld, typically 2-5 mm from the fusion line, corresponding to the zone that experienced the critical temperature range.
Susceptibility by Grade
| Grade | Carbon Content | Sensitization Susceptibility |
|---|---|---|
| 304 | 0.08% max | High (standard carbon grade) |
| 304L | 0.030% max | Low (insufficient carbon for significant carbide precipitation) |
| 316 | 0.08% max | High |
| 316L | 0.030% max | Low |
| 321 | 0.08% max (Ti-stabilized) | Very low (Ti preferentially binds carbon) |
| 347 | 0.08% max (Nb-stabilized) | Very low (Nb preferentially binds carbon) |
| 304H/316H | 0.04-0.10% | Very high (elevated carbon for high-temperature strength) |
Prevention Methods
| Method | Mechanism |
|---|---|
| Use L-grades (304L, 316L) | Low carbon (max 0.030%) provides insufficient carbon for significant Cr23C6 precipitation |
| Use stabilized grades (321, 347) | Titanium or niobium combines with carbon before chromium can, forming stable TiC or NbC |
| Solution annealing after welding | Heating to 1050-1100 deg C dissolves carbides and restores chromium distribution; water quench prevents reprecipitation |
| Minimize heat input | Shorter time in the sensitization range reduces carbide formation |
| Avoid prolonged service at 450-850 deg C | Operational exposure to the sensitization range over time can cause in-service sensitization |
Detection
Weld decay is detected in the field by visual inspection (surface pitting or grooving along the HAZ) and confirmed by metallographic examination. The standard laboratory test for sensitization susceptibility is ASTM A262, which includes five practices (A through E) using different acid solutions to evaluate intergranular corrosion resistance. Practice E (Strauss test, boiling copper sulfate-sulfuric acid) is the most common acceptance test for stainless steel piping materials.
In-service weld decay requires replacement of the affected section, as the grain boundary damage cannot be reversed in the field. Prevention through proper material selection is far more economical than repair.
Leave a Comment
Have a question or feedback? Send us a message.